Canada's Own "Subprime" Borrowing Slapped In The Face

Wednesday, July 9, 2008

I don't have much time to blog but I'd like to just quickly put up a post regarding today's news. This might be redundant, as most of you have already heard (in the MSM or on other blogs), the federal government is tightening mortgage lending practices. A slap on the face, if you will. Not extreme but it is certainly a step in the right direction.

According to the Finance Department announcement, the following changes will be made to the rules of government guaranteed mortgages:

  • Fixing the maximum amortization period for new government-backed mortgages to 35 years;

  • Requiring a minimum down payment of 5% for new government-backed mortgages;

  • 45% maximum TDS ratio (Total debt service ratio - % of gross annual income required to cover payments associated with housing and all other debts and obligations, such as car loans and credit cards)

  • Establishing a consistent 620 minimum credit score requirement; and

  • Introducing new loan documentation standards.


All changes become effective on October 15, 2008 and affect all mortgage lending institutions.

I'm afraid that it's too little, too late. About
62% of first time home buyers choose the 40 year mortgage route as affordability has been stripped in the past years during the real estate bubble. Is this the government's own indirect admission that 40 year mortgages are kin of the famous subprime mortgage? No more liar loans with no downpayment, no authentic documentation and relaxed lending. This will certainly put further downward pressure on prices. In addition, the pool of buyers just shrunk dramatically. The implications of this announcement will be widespread. The government should have done away with the 35 year mortgages as well. The market will always correct itself. Those who forced affordability and bought in the last two years will have a nasty financial ending.

Now, the pressure will be squarely on the sellers. Those now wanting to get out because of the new changes will have to take a financial loss. Remember we are still at record inventory levels. To sell in this marketplace would mean to lower expectations and prices dramatically. On the already over-saturated condo front in Calgary, watch for more intensive promotions (free cars, free gym passes, free trips, first born children, free home entertainment systems, free kitchen makeovers, etc.).

Now I wonder if Ed Jensen will recant his statement in Creb's June report that the market will pick up in activity in the Fall?

I'm expecting realtors (some who are struggling) across Canada to further increase their advertising/marketing budgets from now till October 15, 2008. With sales down 30%-40% yoy already, what will most of them do after that date?

I can already envision the new emergency marketing slogan:
"The best time to buy is now - before October 15, 2008."


12 comments:

Anonymous said...

Take the haircut now. Low-balling now will at least keep you in an equity-positive space. People are still looking because they need to. Help them get in cheaper and both parties win. Riding this one out will leave many broke... Broke in the sense home equity was/is their nest-egg. Finding a mortgage-free situation ASAP... whilst making sure you have secured employment close to your new debt-free 'bunker'.... seems to me one of the smartest plays around. If buying here, make sure you are five minutes from light-rail, or can walk/bike to work. Those negihbourhoods close to LRT will at least have a reasonable chance of maintaining some of their appeal... in a fiscal sense....

Anonymous said...

Mike from the Alberta blog is probably the biggest fool ever. He'll be catching the falling knives one at a time.

Anonymous said...

Ed Jensen, you should be fired. But hey it's ok. The shit that comes from your mug. Will one day bite you in the ass. Element of karma. The market will crash like no other. And you will be fired or forced to resign. With no dignity, face or respect from anyone.

Ed - time to call a spade a spade.

Anonymous said...

It is always an interesting situation that forces a government to cut in with restrictions. I don't know whether or not this will be of that much significance. I mean cutting the max amortization period by 5 years doesn't seem that much dramatic. As a Toronto real estate agent I guess that the one thing that is for sure is the slight downward trend of real estate prices. This would mean good news for buyers who had been put through the rigger in the past few years.

BearTruth said...

Good question TRE. I think one of the new changes which elimnates 0 down will impact the pool of buyers. If we look at findcalgary.ca you'll see that the pending sales are down. We are heading to life after the Stampede so there is no longer an excuse for small sales. Perhaps the action of the major banks of removing 40 yr mortgages immediately will have an impact. The negative perceptions associated with anything real estate in today's society has many buyers worried about the future. We live in such a erratic society. Stagflation, rising energy + food prices, stock market roller coasters, tensions in the Middle East etc. I think that overall the human condition being so volatile, alot of potential buyers have put home ownership on the backburner for now. The future is so unpredictable right now in just about everything - including real estate. Things are on such a bigger scale nowadays.

Plus, all these new changes favour potential buyers. With each passing day, more money is saved translating to a bigger downpayment. So bitter renters et al have nothing to lose.

hybrid car said...

Alberta Advantage was no myth -- it was a lie It was all a lie. And everyone was blinded.

Anonymous said...

it sounds to me like there are a bunch of angry people in here wanting the market to fail, either that or you missed your boat on buying....sucks to be you...with oil prices at around 140 dollars a barrel albertas economy is going strong this is just a blip on the market!

Anonymous said...

Hi,

I agree with all you people that they have not done a great deal. All they did id very little and it won't make great deal in this regard.
Rightly said that everyone there was blind.

Anonymous said...

I enjoy following your blog! The Bend Oregon real estate market continues to be slow. It looks like a good time to buy in your area.

Hard Money Lenders Direct in California said...

CALIFORNIA HOME SALES UP UN JULY

California Real Estate market gave signs of relief. Home sales went up 12.3 percent in July compare to the same month last year. According the Quick Data, a company that monitors Real Estate Activity nationwide.

Of the homes sold 44.8 percent were foreclosure resales.

The median home price last month was 318,000 down 3% from 328,000 for the month before and down 33.5 percent from July a year ago. Most of the drop in home prices is due to the depreciation properties are facing because of the mortgage meltdown.

Not even the most knowledgeable Real Estate indicators know exactly where the market is going. Foreclosure activity is at record levels, banks are asking for tougher requirements, non-owner occupied homes are almost impossible to re-finance.

Anonymous said...

Calgary real estate is going to go seriously down.

But montgomery is awesome!!

Anonymous said...

Hey I'm interested to see what your thinking about the calgary real estate bubble now in 2012... New posts!